Ufton Nervet rail crash

Ufton Nervet rail crash
43019, the locomotive leading the derailed HST, pictured in 2003
Details
Date	6 November 2004 18:12 GMT
Location	Ufton Nervet, Berkshire
Coordinates	51.41472°N 1.11499°W / 51.41472; -1.11499
Country	United Kingdom
Line	Reading to Taunton Line
Operator	First Great Western
Service	17:35 London Paddington to Plymouth
Cause	Obstruction on line
Statistics
Trains	1
Passengers	200–300
Deaths	7
Injured	120
List of rail accidents in the United Kingdom

The Ufton Nervet rail crash occurred on 6 November 2004 when a passenger train collided with a stationary car on a level crossing on the Reading–Taunton line near Ufton Nervet, Berkshire, England. The collision derailed the train, and seven people—including the drivers of the train and the car—were killed. An inquest found that all railway personnel and systems were operating correctly, and the crash was caused by the suicide of the car driver.

In the 10 years after the crash, four further fatal incidents took place on the level crossing and a near-miss occurred when a train traversed the crossing without the barriers lowered. The level crossing was closed and replaced by a road bridge in 2016.

Background

Ufton Nervet level crossing

The level crossing pictured in 2012

Ufton Nervet level crossing was an automatic half-barrier level crossing (AHBC) situated on the Reading–Taunton branch of the Great Western Main Line between Theale and Aldermaston stations. In the United Kingdom, AHBCs are used on roads where traffic is unlikely to block the crossing and where the line speed is not more than 100 miles per hour (160 km/h). Ufton Nervet AHBC was situated on Ufton Lane, an unclassified road connecting the A4 (between Reading and Newbury) with the village of Ufton Nervet in Berkshire. The railway at the crossing is surrounded by fields, and was a short distance from the A4.

When the barriers are lowered at AHBCs, they extend only across the entrances to the crossing, leaving the exits clear. The crossing sequence—comprising flashing lights, alarms, and the barriers—is triggered automatically by approaching trains when they activate a treadle known as the strike-in point. The time given for the train to approach the crossing is dictated by the speed of the line and is sufficient to allow road users to clear the crossing; the minimum time permitted for this is 27 seconds. At Ufton Nervet, the strike-in point was 1,907 yards (1,744 m) from the crossing, which gave 39 seconds for trains travelling at the line speed of 100 miles per hour (160 km/h). The crossing was located after a slight right-hand bend, and the maximum visibility of the crossing for drivers on the down line was 640 yards (585 m); a train travelling at line speed would cover this distance in 13 seconds.

Car driver

The car driver was Brian Drysdale, a 48-year-old chef employed at Wokefield Park, approximately 7 miles (11 km) from Ufton Nervet. He was concerned about the upcoming results from a recent HIV test, thinking that he had contracted the virus from a relationship in the late 1990s and possibly believing that he had developed AIDS. He spoke to NHS Direct in the week preceding his death, saying that he had had suicidal thoughts and thought he was having a nervous breakdown. On 6 November 2004, Drysdale tried four times to telephone the clinic who were testing him for HIV, but it was closed for the weekend. That day he left work at 17:30 GMT and drove to the level crossing.

Train and crew

The train involved in the crash was the 17:35 First Great Western (FGW) service from London Paddington to Plymouth, carrying headcode 1C92. The train consisted of ten vehicles—the leading Class 43 power car (43019; City of Swansea / Dinas Abertawe), eight passenger coaches, and a trailing Class 43 power car (43029). Its driver was Stan Martin, who had worked on the railway network for almost 40 years, and had been a driver since 1974. Three further crew members were aboard the train—two train managers and a customer host serving in the buffet car.

Collision

On 6 November 2004, the train departed Paddington on time at 17:35, making its first scheduled stop at Reading before departing there one minute late at 18:03. After clearing speed restrictions at Southcote Junction, the train accelerated towards the line speed of 100 miles per hour (160 km/h).

Immediately preceding the collision, an off-duty police officer with Thames Valley Police happened upon Drysdale manoeuvring his Mazda 323 between the barriers on the level crossing. Drysdale appeared to ignore the officer, who was flashing his headlights and sounding his horn. At 18:11, the train reached the strike-in point, triggering the crossing sequence. The police officer attempted to use the emergency telephone at the crossing.

Travelling at 98 miles per hour (158 km/h), Martin applied the emergency brake 2–3 seconds before the collision. At 18:12, the train collided with the car. The impact trapped the car's engine block beneath the train's leading axle, lifting the wheelset and causing the bogie to yaw. This in turn made wheel flanges climb and derail. The train continued upright for 91 metres (299 ft) when it reached a set of points at the start of a loop, causing a "catastrophic derailment" of all vehicles. The leading power car came to rest 360 metres (1,180 ft) from the level crossing. The carriages were at varying angles relative to both the vertical and the direction of travel, and the third passenger carriage had been folded horizontally around a bogie after it embedded in an embankment.

Six people were killed at the scene: the car's driver, the train driver, and four passengers. A fifth passenger died in hospital the following day. At least two (and as many as four) of the fatalities were caused by passengers being ejected through broken windows.

Aftermath

The police officer who witnessed the incident called 999 and was able to accurately describe the location to emergency services. He could not see the train in the darkness, but using a torch was able to see the wreckage of the car and Drysdale's body, which had been dragged 30 feet (9 m) from the point of collision and was in the downside cess. The officer continued along the track where passengers were leaving the wreckage via broken windows and using mobile phones to see in the dark. One of the train managers attempted to use a lineside signal post telephone, but the cables had been damaged in the derailment. At 18:21, he used his mobile phone to contact the Integrated Electronic Control Centre in Swindon. Shortly after, he spoke to the other train manager who informed him that he had deployed track circuit interrupters.

The first fire appliance arrived at the scene at 18:25, the first ambulance at 18:31, and representatives from Thames Valley Police and the British Transport Police both at 18:35. In total, the scene was attended by 180 police officers, 84 fire crew, 50 ambulance crew, and 36 doctors and paramedics. Crews arrived in 22 fire appliances and 25 ambulances.

Between 200 and 300 passengers were estimated to have been on board. Of these, 120 were injured, 71 were admitted to hospital, and 18 described as having serious injuries. Minor injuries were initially treated at the nearby Winning Hand pub.

The railway was blocked until 16 November, with local services being replaced by rail replacement bus services and longer-distance services travelling from Reading to Westbury via Swindon. After the reopening of the line, a temporary speed restriction was in force to allow bedding-in of the new track ballast. Leading car 43019 was written off in the collision and was subsequently scrapped. Trailing power car 43029 sustained only minor damage and was later returned to service, eventually being renamed Caldicot Castle.

Investigation and inquest

An investigation was carried out by Thames Valley Police and British Transport Police, and reports were prepared by the Health and Safety Executive.

The Rail Safety and Standards Board (RSSB) published a preliminary report on 1 February 2005 which stated that there was no evidence that maintenance condition of the train contributed to the derailment, and there was no evidence that Network Rail or First Great Western staff were deficient in their fitness for duty. The investigation found that the automatic half-barrier equipment and its associated ancillary equipment were properly maintained, in good condition, and operated correctly at the time of the incident. It also reported that the train driver was following normal operating procedures. It found that the loss of lighting in all coaches following the crash made passengers' orientation and egress difficult.

The RSSB report concluded that while converting the crossing to a CCTV-monitored crossing would lower risk of annual fatalities from 1 in 88,000 to 1 in 760,000, the value of the estimated safety benefits was significantly lower than the £1 million cost of the conversion works. The risk of 1 in 88,000 was deemed to be tolerable provided measures were in place to ensure the risk was as low as reasonably practicable. The report made recommendations including improving emergency communications at the level crossing and moving a set of points whose position was a factor in the train's derailment. Network Rail implemented all the safety recommendations. The RSSB subsequently undertook research into improving seat and table design on board passenger carriages, as well as the effect of two-point seat belts on minimising passenger injuries during incidents. The report concluded that two-point seat belts would cause more injury to passengers in the majority of incidents, and the RSSB recommended they were not installed. Later studies drew a similar conclusion with three-point seat belts.

RSSB also conducted an R&D programme into requirements for train windows. The report identified that although broken windows resulted in passengers being ejected from carriages at Ufton Nervet, the ability to break windows after an incident is crucial for passengers to escape. A 2007 report stated that the introduction of laminated glass would provide "significantly better passenger containment protection in accidents" than toughened glass. In a consultation with emergency services it was established that laminated glass would still allow rescuers to access trapped passengers.

On 1 June 2005 it was announced that an inquest into the crash would be held at Windsor Guildhall. The inquest, due to open on 17 October 2005, was delayed because of a dispute over whether the families of the victims should be given legal aid. The inquest finally began in October 2007, after Mr Justice Owen overturned Bridget Prentice's original decision to deny legal aid. The jury heard the testimony of the police officer witness, who stated that Drysdale did not appear to be acting with any urgency; he believed that the crash was caused by a suicide attempt. A forensic investigator told the inquest that he had been able to determine that the car had been parked on the level crossing with its engine and lights switched off. Its fuel tank still contained petrol, which the inquest heard suggested that the car had not broken down.

In 2007 the Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) described how the absence of an obstacle deflector on the leading power car, as well as the presence of the traction motor and gearbox on its leading axle, increased the likelihood of debris becoming caught beneath the axle. This likelihood was increased by the collision occurring at a level crossing, where the deck surface is level with the rail head. During the inquest, David Main—whose partner and daughter were killed—described how "trains are not safe [...] If laminated glass had been fitted they wouldn't have been [ejected from the carriage]". The county coronor stated that Drysdale's mental health was a "key clue to the cause of the tragedy" and the results of a psychological analysis would play an "active part" in explaining why he parked his car on the crossing. On 1 November 2007 the inquest returned the verdict that the crash was caused by the car driver's suicide and that the train driver and five passengers were unlawfully killed. The coroner described the incident as "a unique set of circumstances that had resulted in catastrophic consequences".

Subsequent events

Royal Humane Society awards

In 2005 the Royal Humane Society awarded its bronze medal to two passengers who had assisted those injured and trapped after the crash, as well as having found two of the fatalities. The two men found nine-year-old Louella Main and the body of her mother Anjanette Rossi; both had been ejected from the train during the crash. One of the men testified to the 2007 inquest:

We came across a young person on the tracks [and] could see blood coming from the little girl's head and she had a little pulse [...] We were trying our hardest to keep her going.

Main died of her injuries. One of the men found a clergyman who had been a passenger on the train, and got him to walk back to the bodies to say a prayer.

Memorials

The memorial garden, pictured in 2022

The Ufton Memorial Garden was "dedicated to all those affected" by the collision. A plaque at the memorial reads "For all those affected by the catastrophic derailment of the First Great Western 17.35 Paddington to Plymouth train on 6 November 2004 [...] One event, many realities". Originally located on the south side of the railway line, the garden was relocated and joined with one dedicated to Martin in 2015 when preparatory work for the road bridge began.

First Great Western named power car 43139 Driver Stan Martin 5 June 1960 – 6 November 2004 as a tribute to the train's driver. When 43139 was acquired by ScotRail in 2019, the name was transferred to GWR's 43198 alongside that of driver Brian Cooper who died in the 1999 Ladbroke Grove rail crash.

Further incidents

After the 2004 crash there were fatal incidents at the crossing in 2009, 2010, 2012, and 2014. The 2010 death was found not suspicious. The coroner's inquest into the 2012 death recorded an open verdict as there was insufficient evidence to be certain that that fatality was the result of suicide. The 2012 collision also caused injury to the InterCity 125 driver. The circumstances surrounding the 2014 fatality were not treated as suspicious.

There was a near miss at Ufton Nervet on 4 September 2011, when a train passed the crossing at 61 miles per hour (98 km/h) without the barriers lowered nor the lights illuminated. The driver, having seen a car on the lane, applied the emergency brake and stopped the train 520 yards (480 m) beyond the crossing. The RAIB investigated the cause, and found that the crossing was being operated locally by a level crossing attendant who had not received instruction from the signaller (at Thames Valley Signalling Centre in Didcot) to close the crossing. The report concluded that the incident was likely a result of work overload on the signaller.

Level crossing closure and replacement bridge

The now-disused level crossing and replacement road bridge (left) pictured in 2022

Following the 2011 near-miss incident, the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers (RMT) said that AHBCs are prohibited in some countries as unsafe, and that "level crossings on high speed train lines should be banned and replaced with bridges [or] underpasses". In July 2012, Network Rail announced that the crossing was due for renewal and it was considering either a like-for-like replacement, converting the crossing to full barriers, or installing a bridge. On the tenth anniversary of the 2004 incident, and shortly after the 2014 fatality, the RMT repeated calls for the crossing to be made safe "[with] no more delays".

In April 2015, Network Rail submitted plans for a road bridge to the east of the crossing. West Berkshire Council approved these in August 2015 and preparatory work began the following month. Construction began in April 2016, and the bridge was officially opened on 16 December 2016. The site of the old crossing was converted for use as a Road Rail Access Point (RRAP) for rail maintenance vehicles to access the railway.

See also

• List of British rail accidents
• 2005 Glendale train crash, in Los Angeles, caused by vehicle left on tracks after driver changed mind about suicide, killing 11

External links

• Railways Archive